Games and Rings
  • A Blog for Olympic Sports Fans

Trying to Decipher The U.S. Soccer Mess After "LFG"

9/16/2021

 

Despite A New U.S. Soccer Overture, Differences Remain

LFG (2021)
A Quick Film Review

So...the continuing issue of equal pay within U.S. Soccer - the national governing body for the men's and women's national teams - resurfaced publicly today with an offer by the office to serve both teams an equal contract.

A win? Well....let's revisit how we got here through a look at this summer's LFG, documenting the multi-year effort by the women's team (USWNT) to receive equal pay to the USMNT.
Picture
I'll be brief: in 2019, the USWMNT filed a lawsuit against their employers (U.S. Soccer) alleging illegal pay discrimination based on gender. While the USWNT receives pay and bonuses based on performance and play, the amount (per performance and play) pales in comparison to what the USMNT receives - by multiple factors. Although in recent years, the USWMNT has earned more in total, it's been a result of working harder - i.e. performing better - than the USMNT. In essence, the women have to work harder (win more) to earn the same as under-performing men.

There's the essence of LFG, as the production speaks with both team members (notably Megan Rapinoe, Christen Press, Becky Sauerbrunn, Kelley O'Hara, Jessica McDonald, and Sam Mewis), and legal & PR representatives as they navigate the proceedings.

It's a compelling argument. Simply put, the USWMNT is paid less than the USMNT, even despite comparative over-performance. LFG presents an entirely empathetic view toward the USWMNT's plight, aided by the absence of direct U.S. Soccer contribution (a disclaimer notes the federation declined comment). Any discussion of U.S. Soccer's position is examined through the plaintiff's interpretation of the federation's often ham-handed public posturing and court actions.

It's a good watch. And will pull you toward the USWNT cause...and cause wonder at what strategy U.S. Soccer is really employing. By the end of the film, taking us into early 2020, the equal pay argument in the lawsuit is dismissed (with an appeal pending) but an equal treatment portion proceeds.

Cut to yesterday, and U.S. Soccer announces an offer of equal pay contracts. The catch, of course there is one, is that for USWMNT pay to rise, USMNT pay will need to drop...a condition that is hard to envision the USMNT accepting. And the ball now is back in the USWNT's court. Of course, a real win for the women is for rate-of-pay to rise up to the men's level - without the men dropping.

​U.S. Soccer is also passing the buck a bit by shifting the root of pay discrepancy to the bonus discrepancy offered by FIFA (the international federation). True, FIFA doles out more money for the men, but how each national body (like U.S. Soccer) distributes that is up to each body.

Regardless, there doesn't seem to be any immediate thawing of positions, at least in public, with tit-for-tat announcements  on social media.

USSF's PR stunts and bargaining through the media will not bring us any closer to a fair agreement. In contrast, we are committed to bargaining in good faith to achieve equal pay and the safest working conditions possible. The proposal that USSF made recently to us does neither. https://t.co/lzchRa0hea

— USWNT Players (@USWNTPlayers) September 15, 2021

An offer on paper of identical contracts to the USWNT and USMNT, and to discuss equalizing prize money, is real, authentic and in good faith. A publicity stunt is a 90-minute one-sided movie. https://t.co/iCdiiCRYFN

— U.S. Soccer Comms (@ussoccer_comms) September 15, 2021
Granted, it's confusing, and nuanced. On one hand - yes, women deserve equal pay, especially in the U.S. It's equal pay for equal work...and there's the rub. Maintaining dominance in a less-competitive (but, yes, strengthening) global women's game is not exactly equal to competitiveness on the men's side. Where that "not exactly equal" lies is hard, as certainly the women work, train, and commit just as much - if not more - than the men. Where do you equate global competitiveness? Add in that the women are arguably as popular and audience/revenue-generating as the men, and, well...
​
Sigh. In any case...can't we all just get along? And agree to pay everyone what they agree they deserve? Not sure we'll see the end soon.

Comments are closed.
    Above: Athens' Kallimarmaro, the site of the 1896 Summer Olympics


    About This Blog

    An Olympics fan blog celebrating all things Olympic sport athletes

    Picture
    Read about me.

    Navigate It

    Celebrating Olympic sport athletes with news links, social media peeks, and more, seen through the cheeky lens of this particular, passionate fan.

    ​Check out:
     A Little Roundup
    Get caught up on the athletes of Olympic sports with a collection of links to recent news and feature stories

    Let's Get Social
    Taking a look at what some of your favorite Olympic sport athletes are up to on social media away from competition.

    They are the Champions
    Congratulations to the world champions of Olympic sports!

    Athletes Worth Watching
    Who are some emerging Olympic sport athletes worth keeping an eye on for the future?

    ​Ramblings and Things
    ​
    I have my own comment and opinions sometimes!

    A Quick Review
    Quick thoughts on Olympic sports-related films, art, books, TV, etc. that I've come across .
    p.s. see my Bookshop!

    Picture
    Me at Rio 2016's Barra Olympic Park


    Follow Me

    Twitter
    Instagram
    ​
    Spotify
    Medium
    ​
    Bookshop
    Post.
    Mastodon
    Tumblr

    Favorite Sites

    The IOC
    The Olympic Museum
    Olympic World Library
    ​Intl Olympic Academy
    ​Team USA
    World Athletics
    ​Athletics Integrity Unit
    WADA
    Court of Arbitration
    Around the Rings
    Inside the Games
    GamesBids.com
    The Sports Examiner
    ​AP Olympics
    ​AP Winter Olympics
    NBC Olympic Talk
    NY Times ​Olympics
    USA TODAY Olympics
    Wiki Summer Olympics
    Wiki Winter Olympics
    ​Athlete365
    ​
    Global Athlete
    ​Olympic Historians
    World Olympians Assoc.
    ​Games Architecture​
    Art of the Olympians
    Olympic.org Results
    ​Olympedia
    ​Olympstats
    ​
    Olympian Database
    ​On This Day in Sports
    ​Coubertin Speaks
    ​Olympic City Project
    ​
    Keep the Flame Alive
    Off The Podium
    The Games Odyssey
    ​Totallympics
    ​Qualifying to the Games
    ​Lost Olympians
    ​
    Olympians 1964 to 2020
    All Sports Books Reviews
    Outsports
    ​
    Queerstory Files
    ​Paris 2024
    ​Milan Cortina 2026
    Los Angeles 2028


    Categories

    All
    A Little Roundup
    Alpine Skiing
    Amsterdam 1928
    Ancient Olympics
    Aquatics
    Archery
    Artistic Swimming
    Athens 1896
    Athens 2004
    Athlete Spotlight
    Athlete Worth Watching
    Atlanta 1996
    Badminton
    Baseball
    Basketball
    Basketball 3x3
    Beach Volleyball
    Beijing 2008
    Beijing 2022
    Berlin 1936
    Biathlon
    Bobsled
    Boxing
    Breaking
    Canoe/Kayak
    Cross Country Skiing
    Curling
    Cycling
    Cycling BMX
    Cycling Mountain Bike
    Cycling Road
    Cycling Track
    Demonstration Sports
    Diving
    Equestrian
    Fencing
    Field Hockey
    Figure Skating
    Freestyle Skiing
    Golf
    Gymnastics
    Handball
    Helsinki 1952
    Ice Hockey
    Innsbruck 1976
    IOC
    Judo
    Karate
    Let's Get Social
    London 1908
    London 1948
    London 2012
    Los Angeles 1932
    Los Angeles 1984
    Los Angeles 2028
    Luge
    Melbourne 1956
    Mexico City 1968
    Milano Cortina 2026
    Modern Pentathlon
    Montreal 1976
    Moscow 1980
    Munich 1972
    Non-Olympic Sports
    Nordic Combined
    Olympics
    Olympic Sports Media
    On This Date
    Other
    Paralympics
    Paris 2024
    Pyeongchang 2018
    Rhythmic Gymnastics
    Rio 2016
    Rome 1960
    Rowing
    Rugby Sevens
    Sailing
    Salt Lake City 2002
    Sarajevo 1984
    Seoul 1988
    Shooting
    Short Track Speedskating
    Skateboarding
    Skeleton
    Ski Jumping
    Ski Mountaineering
    Snowboarding
    Soccer (football)
    Sochi 2014
    Softball
    Speed Skating
    Sport Climbing
    Squash
    Stockholm 1912
    Summer Olympics
    Surfing
    Swimming
    Sydney 2000
    Table Tennis
    Taekwondo
    Tennis
    They Are The Champions
    Tokyo 1964
    Tokyo 2020
    Track And Field
    Trampolining
    Triathlon
    Volleyball
    WADA
    Water Polo
    Weightlifting
    Winter Olympics
    Wrestling


    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014


    To opt-out of cookies, and to read this site's privacy policy, read the Policy page.

    The following link is listed for Mastodon site verification purposes only:
    Mastodon

    RSS Feed


Proudly powered by Weebly