Games and Rings
  • A Blog for Olympic Sports Fans

World Athletics On the Wrong Side of History, Again

9/11/2020

 
In January 2008, World Athletics (then known as the International Amateur Athletic Federation, or IAAF) ruled that double-leg amputee Oscar Pistorius was ineligible for able-bodied competition. This, based on research they conducted on his "cheetah" blades of prosthesis, determining an unfair advantage over able-bodied competitors. Pistorius subsequently went to appeal, and emerged victorious two months later at the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS). This court ruled that Pistorius' blades did not give him an advantage, or at least that the IAAF did not prove that they did, based on further independent research. A quick turnaround then was needed from the IAAF in the world of public relations, and both the IAAF and the International Olympic Committee issued quick statements of support for Pistorius' ambitions.

Pistorius did not qualify for Beijing 2008, but he did for subsequent able-bodied competitions, including the IAAF's 2011 World Championships (earning a silver medal in the 4x400 meter relay) and the London 2012 Olympics. At London, he became a superstar icon of the sport, noticeably marketed as a draw by broadcasters and media partners. Oscar Pistorius was a welcome example of the inclusive and welcoming spirit of competition that the Olympics and its signature sport, track and field, can showcase. 

Cut to this week, where Caster Semenya was dealt another blow in her appeal for World Athletics to allow her to compete. Semenya, who had been competing under World Athletics competition, and a two-time Olympic gold medalist already, was suddenly told in 2018 that she was not eligible anymore in her target event of 800 meters.

At that time, the IAAF classified runners of Difference of Sexual Development (DSD) as ineligible to compete in races from 400 meters to a mile, unless they submitted to a testosterone-reducing regimen. In short, women they deemed as having too much testosterone were - are - banned from those distances.

This immediately targeted Semenya, long subjected to criticisms of her femininity counting back to her London 2012 debut, as well as both of the other Rio 2016 800 meters medalists, Francine Niyonsaba and Margaret Wambui. Most recently, sprinter Aminatou Seyni has been blocked from her best event of 400 meters due to the restrictions. Semenya appealed the IAAF's ruling, first at the CAS and then the Swiss Supreme Court, losing the latter and maybe final case this week.

World Athletics maintains their new rules are based on science and research, and that preventing women with higher-testosterone levels from competing naturally maintains an "even playing field". But when is naturally-inherent sporting skill beholden to an "even playing field"? I don't recall anyone telling swimmer Michael Phelps that his specific and unique natural-born attributes were an unfair advantage.

One striking item about the World Athletics DSD rule is that it only restricts affected athletes from specific events, from the 400 meters to the mile. Why no restrictions from the other events their research showed as possibly compromised by DSD athletes, the pole vault and hammer throw? Put simply, there's no need for those events to have restrictions, as there isn't currently any (presumed) DSD athlete significantly competing in them. So, the rule is really about targeting Semenya, and Niyonsaba and others, and artificially ensuring closer competition.

Not to bash Phelps, but his continued dominance over his rivals has been celebrated time after time. Why should a woman's dominance not be as celebrated as unique?

I hold still to my initial thought when I read of Semenya's latest setback this week. She was born a woman. She was born with higher testosterone than other woman may be. She is still a woman. She should be able to compete as one.

Another troubling aspect is that, so far to the public's eye, the DSD ruling is affecting only African-born women: Semenya (from South Africa), Niyonsaba (Burundi), Wangui (Kenya), Senyi (Niger). Aspects of European-based bureaucrats deciding who is and isn't a "legal" woman has unfortunate shades of colonial racism. Again, some women may be born with higher testosterone. They are still women. Semenya's particular against-the-standardized-grain of femininity is surely a factor as well.

​World Athletics had - has - an opportunity for applauding natural diversity of athletes, and in this case, of its women. And, as with its initial restrictions on Oscar Pistorius, the governing body has woefully missed it. Rather than standing for what it perceived to be correct femininity, it would have been far more braver and inclusive to proudly stand for naturally-given talent, no matter how dominating. Remember how celebratory Pistorius' appearance had been?

Wherever Semenya goes next -she has entertained the idea of trying the 200 meters - she remains a champion of the sport, and of womanhood. I'll be cheering.
Picture
(from left) Niyonsaba, Semenya, and Wangui - the three women on the Rio 2016 podium

Comments are closed.

    About This Blog

    Highlights from the world of Olympic sports, focused on the athletes, and as seen through the cheeky lens of this one particular, passionate fan.

    Navigate It

    ​A Little Roundup
    Links to Olympic sport headlines and news, with a focus on the athletes

    Athlete Worth Watching
    Finding emerging names and stories in Olympic sports to keep an eye on

    Let's Get Social
    Sharing intriguing and provocative posts from Olympic sport athletes

    ​Ramblings and Things
    ​
    I have my own thoughts on Olympic sport news and athletes sometimes!
    Read more on me here.

    Picture
    At Rio 2016's Barra Olympic Park
    Header: Kallimamaro stadium in Athens, site of the first modern Olympics in 1896

    Follow Me

    Picture
    Tweets by @GamesandRings

    Picture

    Picture

    Favorite Sites

    The IOC
    The Olympic Channel
    The Olympic Museum
    ​
    Team USA
    World Athletics
    WADA
    ​Athletics Integrity Unit
    Court of Arbitration
    Around the Rings
    Inside the Games
    GamesBids.com
    NBC Olympic Talk
    NY Times ​Olympics
    USA TODAY Olympics
    ​AP Olympics
    Wiki Summer Olympics
    Wiki Winter Olympics
    ​Athlete365
    ​Olympic Historians
    World Olympians Assoc.
    ​Games Architecture​
    Art of the Olympians
    Olympic.org Results
    ​Olympedia
    ​Olympstats
    ​On This Day in Sports
    ​Olympic City Project
    ​
    Keep the Flame Alive
    ​Totallympics Fan Forum
    ​Lost Olympians
    ​
    Olympians 1964 to 2020
    Outsports
    ​
    Queerstory Files
    Rio 2016
    Pyeongchang 2018
    Tokyo 2020
    ​Beijing 2022
    ​Paris 2024
    ​Milan Cortina 2026
    Los Angeles 2028


    Categories

    All
    A Little Roundup
    Alpine Skiing
    Aquatics
    Archery
    Artistic Swimming
    Athens 1896
    Athens 2004
    Athlete Spotlight
    Athlete Worth Watching
    Atlanta 1996
    Badminton
    Baseball
    Basketball
    Basketball 3x3
    Beach Volleyball
    Beijing 2008
    Beijing 2022
    Biathlon
    Bobsled
    Books & Media
    Boxing
    Breaking
    Canoeing
    Cross Country Skiing
    Curling
    Cycling
    Cycling BMX
    Cycling Mountain Bike
    Cycling Road
    Cycling Track
    Diving
    Equestrian
    Fencing
    Field Hockey
    Figure Skating
    Freestyle Skiing
    Golf
    Gymnastics
    Handball
    Ice Hockey
    IOC
    Judo
    Karate
    Let's Get Social
    London 1908
    London 1948
    London 2012
    Los Angeles 1984
    Los Angeles 2028
    Luge
    Melbourne 1956
    Mexico City 1968
    Modern Pentathlon
    Montreal 1976
    Munich 1972
    Nordic Combined
    Olympics
    On This Date
    Other
    Paralympics
    Paris 2024
    Rhythmic Gymnastics
    Rio 2016
    Rome 1960
    Rowing
    Rugby Sevens
    Sailing
    Seoul 1988
    Shooting
    Short Track Speedskating
    Skateboarding
    Skeleton
    Ski Jumping
    Snowboarding
    Soccer (football)
    Sochi 2014
    Softball
    Speed Skating
    Sport Climbing
    Squash
    Surfing
    Swimming
    Sydney 2000
    Table Tennis
    Taekwondo
    Tennis
    Ternnis
    Tokyo 1964
    Tokyo 2020
    Track And Field
    Trampolining
    Triathlon
    Volleyball
    WADA
    Water Polo
    Weightlifting
    Winter Olympics
    Wrestling


    Archives

    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014


    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly